The September 2004 issue of Seattle magazine trumpeted its main feature, "Top
Doctors," and highlighted the fact that it had selected Seattle's "Top
Alternative Practitioners." I tore to the section of the local
publication listing Seattle's top alternative docs—I was
not surprised to find that alternative medicine had been compartmentalized
into naturopathy, chiropractic, acupuncture, osteopathy. What was particularly
galling was the fact that the great leaders and minds of alternative
medicine, many of whom are M.D.'s who decided not to practice
conventional medicine, would not be welcomed by this classification
of alternative practitioners. Licensing prohibits an M.D. from being
referred to as a naturopath; hence, from the viewpoint of the magazine,
M.D.'s practicing alternative medicine do not officially practice
alternative medicine, unless they become licensed in naturopathy, chiropractic,
acupuncture or osteopathy.
In the Seattle area, it would be obvious to honor Jonathan Wright,
M.D. as a top alternative practitioner, but as an M.D., Wright has
no cachet in the magazine's honor system. Nationwide I can think
of many outstanding M.D. alternative doctors who would have never received
honors: Alan Gaby, Robert Atkins, Abram Ber, Emmanuel Cheraskin, Deepak
Chopra, Elmer Cranton, Charles Farr, Garry Gordon, Abram Hoffer, Evarts
Loomis, Theron Randolph, Norman Shealy, Bernie Siegel, Lendon Smith,
Melvyn Werbach, Julian Whitaker, James Carter, James Gordon, John Lee,
Christiane Northrup, William Philpott, Doris Rapp, Bernard Rimland,
Hugh Riordan, Andrew Weil and many others.
The concept that M.D.'s are not alternative practitioners is
not limited to this local magazine. Official study of alternative medicine
generally focuses on traditional, established forms of alternative
medical practice such as naturopathy and acupuncture. The practice
by alternative M.D.'s of orthomolecular medicine, intravenous
vitamin and mineral therapy, chelation, bio-oxidative therapies, ozone
treatment, colonic therapy, glandular therapy, bio-identical hormone
treatment, cell therapy, hyperbaric oxygen, unconventional cancer therapies,
hyperthermia, homeopathy, herbal treatments, nosode therapy, neural
therapy, and detoxification are generally not considered acceptable
alternative practices and, therefore, are not recognized by authorities
or society. The fact of the matter is that a large part of alternative
medicine practice which goes unrecognized officially is conducted by
alternative M.D.'s who use one or more of the aforementioned
therapies. As society and university studies examine alternative medicine
in the future, it will be obligatory to recognize the role M.D.'s
have had in developing alternative medicine.
In this issue of the Townsend Letter for Doctors
and Patients we consider
the role alternative medicine has in treating anxiety disorders. Werbach
spells out in the simplest of terms the effectiveness of B vitamins
in arresting symptoms of agoraphobia (fear of open spaces). Inositol,
Niacinamide, Thiamine, B6 and B12 are all considered key to reversing
anxiety symptoms. For most patient treatments, the B Vitamins must
be used in a "mega-dose" fashion to establish an anti-anxiety
effect. It is a curious phenomenon that for a minority of patients,
B vitamins in mega-doses tend to exacerbate the anxiety symptoms. When
a patient indicates that high dose B-vitamins has had an ill effect
on anxiety and depression symptoms, the practitioner would be well
advised to be very cautious prescribing again mega-dose B-Vitamins.
It is unlikely that the adverse effect of B-vitamins was coincidence—instead,
the patient probably has some hypersensitivity which the B-vitamins
is triggering. The most concerning patient is the anxious patient with
insomnia; B vitamins may worsen the insomnia, assuredly aggravating
the anxiety state. Gaby emphasizes the role that stimulants in the
diet play in creating an anxiety state. His primary target is coffee
drinking and excess caffeine consumption. Gaby reminds us that for
a few individuals even tiny amounts of caffeine will set off the anxious
patient; for these few individuals, a complete elimination of coffee
and caffeine in the diet is mandatory for anxiety relief. Interestingly,
classical homeopathy, as discussed by the Ullmans mandates that patients
omit coffee drinking before being administered the correct remedy.
Homeopathy prohibits the consumption of coffee, as coffee is considered
to be a neutralizer of effective homeopathic treatment. Is it possible
that coffee is hypersensitizing to anxious patients not only because
of the caffeine but also because of the coffee itself?
For those interested in a more scientific discourse on why nutrients
impact anxiety disorders, please read Nick's evaluation of inositol
as a treatment for obsessive compulsive and panic disorder. Wolfe reminds
us that Chinese medicine, particular acupuncture, is a very effective
tool for controlling anxiety and abating more severe psychiatric disorders.
Flaws discusses the rationale of Chinese medicine for anxiety requires
a balancing of qi energy especially in the liver, heart, kidney and
spleen meridians. The role of Chinese medicine in treating anxiety
is documented by Flaws with Hamilton Anxiety Scale tests before and
during treatment with Chinese herbals.
Anecdotally, I should mention my patient's treatment of panic
disorder and anxiety syndrome using a form of neural therapy. This
patient, a woman in her early 40's, suffered for years from panic
disorder, agoraphobia, fatigue syndrome, depression, and cognitive
dysfunctioning. My first treatment recommendations included reduction
in caffeine, food allergy elimination diet, selective use of vitamin,
mineral, amino acid, and essential fatty acid supplements, and homeopathy
(anti-anxiety formulas). Further evaluation indicated a low grade form
of hypothyroidism and treatment with thyroid USP 1/2 grain. To increase
the effectiveness of B Vitamins, I had her self-inject B12 several
times weekly according to the recommendation of orthomolecular psychiatrist,
Newbold. Herbals kava kava and valerian were employed despite the warnings
that this may cause liver toxicity (liver function tests have remained
normal). Despite the variety of treatment supports and continuation
of therapy, she continued to experience panic disorder and anxiety.
A review of her medical history disclosed that she did not experience
anxiety disorder until sustaining a brain concussion, the result of
injury from a domestic violence incident. She had been punched in the
forehead by her husband, knocking her unconscious. The resulting injury
took some time to heal and left an area of sensitivity to touch in
her forehead. Neural therapy, a topic too complicated to discuss here,
claims that painful scarred areas in the body can be the focus of energetic
disturbance leading to medical conditions and disease. Neural therapy
recommends the injection of procaine and/or similar agents in the scarred
area to dissipate the abnormal energetic field. With some trepidation,
I began a form of neural therapy which probably was not acceptable
to neural therapy instructors. I like mixing procaine with B12 and
occasionally using minimal doses of DMSO. I injected the patient through
the scarred area of her forehead with the procaine mixture, injecting
approximately 10cc, in a grid-like pattern across her forehead. She
stated after the treatment that as a child she had been called a "numb-skull," but
this treatment definitely made her one. With the very first treatment,
and with each treatment thereafter, she has had a complete cessation
of anxiety and agoraphobia symptoms for the first time since the domestic
violence assault. She has regained her ability to work and be out in
the community. The treatment seemed to have a half-life; she needed
to be reinjected about a month later to sustain the anti-anxiety effect.
Why this procaine injection treatment of her forehead would control
her anxiety symptoms gives some validity to the idea that scar formation
from past trauma plays an important role in perpetuating anxiety and
depression.
The next two issues of the Townsend Letter examine Women's Health
and Men's Health.
Jonathan Collin, M.D.
|