In
last month's column, I worried about how the political change
of 2006 might impact the politics of alternative medicine. I made a
tacit assumption that Democrats might push for more regulations of
alternative medical practices and nutritional medicine, repudiating
the laissez-faire style of the Republicans. We didn't really
need to wait long. In December, even before the freshmen Democrats
took office, and while Republican office staff were huddled in the
Congressional basement putting out classified ads for new employment,
both the Senate and the House passed legislation regulating over-the-counter
drugs and nutritional supplements.
In a report by Steve Myers of the Natural Products Insider, posted on 12/16/06
at www.naturalproductsinsider.com, the House passage of the Adverse Effects Reporting
Bill for nutritional supplements was announced with unabated excitement. The
bipartisan bill was initially proposed early in the summer by Senators Orrin
Hatch (R-Utah), Tom Harkin (D-Iowa), and Richard Durbin (D-Illinois). The Dietary
Supplement and Non Prescription Drug Consumer Protection Act (S. 3546) requires
reporting of serious adverse effects (AERs) of both over-the-counter drugs and
nutritional supplements. Manufacturers would be required to report within 15
days any adverse effect or incident (AER) to the FDA.
According to Myers, nutritional supplement manufacturers, consumer advocacy groups,
and herbals organizations lauded the passage of this legislation. David Seckman,
executive director of the Natural Products Association, stated that "we
have long said passing this legislation is the responsible, right thing to do
for both the industry and consumers." Seckman thanked his membership, who
sent thousands of letters to Congressmen supporting the passage of this legislation.
Michael McGuffin, president of the American Herbal Products Association (AHPA),
noted that the Senate passed the billed unanimously and the House supported it
by a 2 to 1 vote. Myers reported that the Council for Responsible Nutrition (CRN)'s
president, Steven Mister, praised the legislation: "With this law, consumers
can be assured that if they report to a manufacturer a serious adverse event
they believe may be associated with a supplement product, the agency that regulates
this industry – FDA – will be made aware of that report." Mister
further thought the regulation will offer consumers greater confidence when using
nutritional supplements. "We are confident that ultimately the AER system
will highlight the strong safety record of dietary supplements and allow consumers
to feel increased confidence about the choices they make when taking dietary
supplements." The chairman of the consumer group Citizens for Health, attorney
James S. Turner, noted, "this is a very important piece of legislation
that advances consumer interests within a safe, credible dietary supplement marketplace."
Curiously, Myer did not report that some alternative medical groups did not share
the same viewpoint. The American Association for Health Freedom (AAHF) encouraged
its membership to contact their congressmen and women to defeat this legislation.
Executive Director Brenna Hill of the AAHF worried that passage of this legislation
would undo freedoms Americans now have under the Dietary Supplement Health and
Education Act (DSHEA) of 1994 to freely obtain and use nutritional supplementation
without restriction from government agency oversight. The National Health Federation
(NHF) was also concerned that the passage of S.3546 would be detrimental to consumers' free
use of supplements and would pose a serious threat to the manufacture and distribution
of supplements. The National Health Federation did a policy analysis, which determined
that the AER reporting system would obligate the FDA to engage in greater enforcement
actions with nutritional supplement manufacturers as well as distributors of
such supplements.
It is difficult at this juncture to determine if this legislation will substantially
change the marketplace for nutritional supplements and consumer access to such
products. It is of interest that legislation for AER reporting of nutritional
supplements has been considered numerous times over the past ten years. The DSHEA
legislation argued against AER regulation and effectively blocked passage of
similar bills. Increasing concerns with adulterated drugs (which I will discuss
next issue) may have tipped the balance in favor of a consumer protection act
for nutritional supplements. Still, it is interesting that this legislation's
passage followed the November landslide election for Democrats.
Our February/March
2007 issue focuses on the best of naturopathic medicine. We congratulate
the naturopathic students, faculty, and clinicians who are winners
in our second annual competition, and we thank all the entrants. In general,
submissions for this competition were thoughtful and well-researched. Bastyr
student David Graves' essay, for instance, on Latent Autoimmune Diabetes
of Adults (LADA), considers the presentation of that frequently misdiagnosed
form of diabetes mellitus and reviews possible adjunctive naturopathic treatment
therapies. And in his well-detailed article
on hypothyroidism, Martin Milner,
ND, presents a compelling case for slow-release, compounded thyroid replacement.
Award-winners Jonathan Prousky, ND, ("The Orthomolecular Treatment of
Schizophrenia")
and Ani Hawkinson, UBCNM, ("Nutrigenomics and Nutrigenetics in Whole
Food Nutritional Medicine") also offer noteworthy essays. In addition,
we are pleased to present two companion essays to our prize-winners in which
the deans
of National College of Naturopathic Medicine (essay) and Southwest College of Naturopathic Medicine present their visions
for naturopathic
education in 2007 and the future.
We thank the many individuals who helped to facilitate our competition, including
the deans of naturopathic education at Bastyr University, Bridgeport University
College of Naturopathic Medicine, Canadian College of Naturopathic Medicine,
National College of Naturopathic Medicine, and Southwest College of Naturopathic
Medicine. We would like to encourage all interested students, faculty, and
practicing physicians to submit articles for our next biannual "Best
of Naturopathic Medicine" issue.
Jonathan Collin, MD
|